Choosing the perfect neighborhood in Nassau County, Long Island, can be a daunting task. Franklin Square and Elmont both offer unique lifestyles, amenities, and opportunities that attract families, professionals, and investors alike. This comprehensive comparison will guide you through essential factors such as demographics, schools, real estate, safety, transportation, and more. Whether you’re relocating, investing, or simply exploring, understanding how Franklin Square and Elmont stack up side-by-side will help you make an informed decision that fits your priorities.
Overview of Franklin Square and Elmont
Franklin Square and Elmont are vibrant communities located in Nassau County on Long Island, New York. Both towns feature suburban charm while being conveniently close to New York City, attracting diverse populations seeking a blend of city access and neighborhood tranquilities.
Franklin Square is an unincorporated area within the town of Hempstead, known for its strong community spirit and tree-lined streets. It boasts a population of approximately 30,000 residents and is characterized by well-established neighborhoods and a balanced mix of residential and commercial spaces.
Elmont lies just south of Franklin Square, also part of Hempstead, with a population close to 35,000. It is notably home to the Belmont Park racetrack, a key cultural landmark, and has seen steady growth due to ongoing development projects and enhanced transit connections.
Both towns enjoy easy access to major roadways like the Southern State Parkway, contributing to their desirability among commuters and families alike.
Demographics and Community Character
Understanding the people who call Franklin Square and Elmont home reveals much about daily life, community values, and social dynamics in each town.
Population and Diversity
Franklin Square offers a diverse community with a rich blend of ethnic backgrounds. The population includes a significant percentage of Italian-American and Irish-American families, alongside growing Hispanic and African-American communities, fostering a family-oriented environment with a range of cultural traditions.
Elmont is similarly diverse but features an even more varied demographic profile. It has a strong African-American and Caribbean presence, along with Hispanic and South Asian families contributing to its cultural vibrancy. This diversity translates into multicultural community events, unique local businesses, and an inclusive atmosphere.
Income and Employment
Median household income in Franklin Square tends to be slightly higher than in Elmont, reflecting the area's established middle-class status and proximity to high-paying job centers. Residents often work in healthcare, education, retail, and professional services sectors.
Elmont's median income is competitive but slightly lower on average, attributable to its growing immigrant population and working-class roots. Employment opportunities in Elmont benefit from its proximity to Belmont Park and transport hubs, with many residents commuting to NYC or working in service, transportation, and small business sectors.
Both communities report stable employment rates, supported by Nassau County’s diverse economy and expanding local businesses.
Education and Schools
For families, education quality is paramount — and both Franklin Square and Elmont deliver strong school systems integrated with public and private options.
Franklin Square primarily falls under the Franklin Square Union Free School District and the nearby Sewanhaka Central High School District. Schools such as John Street School and Franklin Square Middle School receive positive ratings for academic achievement, student support, and extracurricular activities. The area also benefits from accessible public libraries and adult education programs.
Elmont belongs mostly to the Sewanhaka Central High School District and the Elmont Union Free School District. Schools here have made strides in improving standardized test scores and offer specialized programs in STEM and the arts. Public library branches serve as educational anchors, while increased funding supports technological upgrades.
Both towns have private school choices ranging from religious institutions to specialized academies, providing additional flexibility for parents seeking alternate curricula.
Real Estate Market Comparison
Real estate is a critical factor whether buying a home or investing in property, with price points, taxes, and housing inventory shaping the market.
Home Prices and Rentals
Franklin Square generally commands higher median home prices due to its mature neighborhoods and sought-after location. Single-family homes dominate the market, with prices typically ranging from $500,000 to $700,000. Rentals tend to be more limited but are available in multi-family units and smaller apartment buildings, averaging around $1,800 to $2,200 per month.
Elmont offers a slightly more affordable real estate market. Median home prices usually fall between $400,000 and $600,000, appealing to first-time buyers and investors. The rental market is more robust here, with a larger supply of apartments and duplexes renting for $1,500 to $1,900 monthly.
Property Taxes and Utilities
Property taxes in both towns align with Nassau County standards but can vary by school district and assessed property values. Franklin Square’s taxes are moderately higher, reflective of its strong school system funding and infrastructure maintenance. Elmont offers marginally lower tax rates, attracting budget-conscious buyers.
Utilities, including water, electricity, and gas, are competitively priced in both towns, with common providers such as PSEG Long Island servicing the area. Utility costs generally fall in line with Long Island averages, essential for calculating overall living expenses.
Cost of Living
https://westhempstead-ny-11580-tg005.lowescouponn.com/ultimate-guide-to-day-trips-from-franklin-square-nyThe cost of living in both Franklin Square and Elmont is above the national average, typical for Nassau County suburbs close to NYC. Housing constitutes the largest expense, followed by transportation, groceries, and healthcare.
Franklin Square ranks slightly higher overall due to property values and household spending trends. Groceries and dining out might cost more because of the town’s upscale shopping corridors, while some transportation expenses decrease thanks to shorter commutes.
Elmont offers a somewhat lower cost of living, appealing to families and individuals looking to balance proximity to urban centers with affordability. Public transportation access and local retail options help maintain reasonable day-to-day costs.
Safety and Crime Rates
Safety is a top concern for anyone considering relocation. Both Franklin Square and Elmont have relatively low crime rates compared to other parts of Nassau County.
Franklin Square benefits from active community policing and neighborhood watch programs. Its crime profile is mostly limited to minor incidents, resulting in a high sense of security among families.
Elmont experiences marginally higher crime stats, particularly related to property crimes, but ongoing community initiatives and collaborations with law enforcement have improved safety perceptions over recent years.
Both towns rank well in county-wide safety reports, with ample police presence and emergency response services.
Transportation and Commute
Access to reliable transportation and manageable commute times is crucial for professionals and families.
Franklin Square is served by the LIRR’s nearby stations and numerous bus routes, allowing commuters to reach Manhattan within 40–50 minutes. Major highways like the Southern State Parkway provide convenient car travel, though rush hour traffic can increase travel times. Parking is generally accessible in residential areas but can be limited near commercial zones.
Elmont’s transportation infrastructure has received recent enhancements, including improved bus service and proximity to the New York City subway extension (7 line). Commute times to NYC average about 45–60 minutes. Belmont Park offers a transit hub that adds convenience for attendees and residents alike.
Both towns support cycling paths and pedestrian-friendly sidewalks, encouraging alternative commuting modes.
Parks, Recreation, and Culture
Community amenities greatly influence lifestyle satisfaction, making parks, cultural venues, and entertainment important considerations.
Attractions and Landmarks
Franklin Square features several well-maintained local parks such as Roosevelt Oval Park and Washington Square Park, allowing for outdoor sports, picnics, and seasonal events. Historical sites and small museums highlight the town’s heritage.
Elmont is famous for Belmont Park, home to the Belmont Stakes horse race, which brings regional tourism and entertainment. Additional parks, like Tucker Park, offer playgrounds and sports facilities, while cultural centers host art and music festivals throughout the year.
Restaurants and Nightlife
Dining options in Franklin Square include family-friendly diners, ethnic eateries, and increasingly trendy cafés catering to a diverse palate. Nightlife is modest but includes lounges and bars suited for casual evenings.
Elmont offers a similar profile with an emphasis on Caribbean, Latin American, and American cuisine. Its nightlife scene has grown alongside local developments, with more pubs and event venues gaining popularity.
Both towns feature shopping plazas with a mix of chain stores and independent boutiques, enhancing everyday convenience.
Healthcare Services
Quality healthcare facilities are vital for long-term wellbeing. Franklin Square hosts several medical offices, dental clinics, and urgent care centers. Nearby hospitals, such as St. Francis Hospital in neighboring Flower Hill, provide specialized services.
Elmont residents access a comparable range of healthcare options, with proximity to Northwell Health facilities and wellness centers offering primary care, pediatrics, and specialty treatments.
Both communities benefit from easy ambulance access and multiple pharmacies ensuring comprehensive health coverage.
Local Economy and Development
Economic vitality ensures sustainable growth and community prosperity.
Franklin Square has a stable local economy fueled by small businesses, retail centers, and service industries. Recent investments focus on revitalizing commercial districts and upgrading public infrastructure.
Elmont is experiencing notable development, including mixed-use projects and transit-oriented development driven by Belmont Park’s redevelopment plans and subway expansion. This growth generates new jobs and increases property values.
Both towns support entrepreneurship and community programs aimed at workforce development.
Politics and Community Involvement
Local governance and civic engagement shape the quality of life in these towns.
Franklin Square residents actively participate in community boards, environmental programs, and volunteer initiatives, promoting neighborhood improvement. Politically, it tends to lean moderate with a focus on education, safety, and development.
Elmont’s political landscape is similar, with strong voter turnout and emphasis on affordable housing, transportation, and social services. Community groups play a pivotal role in organizing cultural events and advocating for residents’ needs.
Both towns take pride in inclusive governance and responsive local authorities.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which town has better schools, Franklin Square or Elmont?
How do property taxes compare between Franklin Square and Elmont?
Property taxes in Franklin Square tend to be slightly higher due to stronger school funding and established infrastructure, while Elmont offers more moderate tax rates.
What is the average commute time from Franklin Square and Elmont to NYC?
Franklin Square averages 40–50 minutes via LIRR or car, whereas Elmont’s commute ranges from 45 to 60 minutes, benefiting from recent transit upgrades.
Which area is safer in terms of crime rates?
Both towns are relatively safe, but Franklin Square reports marginally lower crime statistics, with active community safety programs in place.
How do home prices and rental costs differ between the two communities?
Franklin Square has higher median home prices and fewer rentals, whereas Elmont offers more affordable housing and a larger rental market.
Are there more parks and recreational facilities in Franklin Square or Elmont?
Both towns have ample parks and recreational areas; Franklin Square has more traditional neighborhood parks, while Elmont benefits from large venues like Belmont Park.
What public transportation options are available in each town?
Franklin Square relies on nearby LIRR stations and bus routes; Elmont has enhanced bus services and benefits from the NYC subway 7 line extension.
Which town offers better healthcare facilities?
Healthcare services are comparable, with easy access to hospitals and clinics in and around both towns.
How do these towns compare in terms of community events and nightlife?
Franklin Square features family-oriented events and modest nightlife, while Elmont offers more cultural diversity in events and a growing nightlife scene.
In summary, both Franklin Square and Elmont present compelling options for homebuyers, families, and commuters in Nassau County. Franklin Square appeals with its established neighborhoods, strong schools, and slightly higher safety ratings, while Elmont attracts with affordability, cultural diversity, and transportation improvements. Evaluating your personal priorities in education, budget, commute, and lifestyle will help pinpoint which community best suits your needs. Take time to visit both, explore local resources, and connect with residents or real estate experts to make the most confident choice in 2025.